Recent Historical Comps for Rhys Hoskins

This is probably not going to be a long article but I was curious which players fit the Hoskins profile best in recent history. Carson already established the Hoskins profile as a guy who hits the ball in the air and makes contact.

For that, I searched first basemen that played from 2002 to 2017. I used 2002 because that is the year we started to have batted-ball data. It also means that it mostly covers a high-K era, although it got more extreme recently. As a cut-off, I used 1500 PAs played. 96 players fulfill those criteria.

First, I filtered for an ISO of .200 or greater. I also filtered for a BB% of greater than 9% (because Hoskins also walks), a K% of 20% or smaller, and finally a ground-ball rate of 40% or under.

That leaves a list of just eight names:

Carlos Delgado 1044 4523 244 12.40% 19.50% 0.26 0.298 0.278 0.38 0.538 0.385 134 21.5 38.50%
Derrek Lee 1393 5980 259 11.50% 19.40% 0.222 0.325 0.289 0.374 0.511 0.38 130 31 39.30%
Jeff Bagwell 513 2195 100 13.80% 18.30% 0.22 0.301 0.277 0.382 0.496 0.378 127 12.2 39.70%
Mark Teixeira 1862 8029 409 11.40% 17.90% 0.241 0.282 0.268 0.36 0.509 0.371 127 44.9 38.70%
Anthony Rizzo 885 3799 165 11.20% 16.80% 0.222 0.288 0.269 0.368 0.491 0.369 133 23.8 39.20%
Edwin Encarnacion 1646 6781 342 11.10% 16.50% 0.233 0.272 0.265 0.354 0.498 0.366 126 29.7 36.40%
Rafael Palmeiro 573 2390 122 13.30% 11.50% 0.231 0.249 0.264 0.364 0.495 0.365 120 7.2 32.80%
Paul Konerko 1827 7458 355 10.20% 15.00% 0.211 0.285 0.278 0.357 0.489 0.363 120 18 37.90%
Average 1217.875 5144.375 249.5 0.118625 0.168625 0.23 0.2875 0.2735 0.367375 0.503375 0.372125 127.125 23.5375 0.378125

The list is a pretty good group. It averages 23 career WAR, a 127 wRC+ and a .273/.367/.503 line. The only downside there might be is that the fly-ball profile could supress BABIP some. The group has a .287 BABIP which is below the league average of .300 during that time span, especially if you consider how hard those guys hit the ball. That means that those guys do underperform their K/BB/ISO profile a little bit. For example, Konerko has a very good power/contact/discipline profile that by my math points to more of a 140+ wRC+, but his actual wRC+ is 120. That is the disadvantage of that extreme profile — you are losing some BABIP to fly outs, especially if you hit more balls in the high fly ball range, which tend to be either HRs or outs, and even more so if there is a slightly elevated pop-up rate coming in conjunction with the fly balls.

But overall that doesn’t matter that much if the K/BB/ISO profile is that good; those guys are all really good hitters even with a slightly lower BABIP. Just expect Hoskins’ hit tool to play under his contact rate a little bit due to that Bautista-like profile (who also had that lower-BABIP, pulled-fly-ball profile with great contact and walk rate).

That means Hoskins might be a .265 hitter despite above-average contact, which also makes his SLG play a little bit down on his power, but he should still get on base on a very good clip and produce excellent power. Just be a little careful when looking at his power, contact, and discipline if you want to bank him for a .300 average/.600 SLG for your fantasy team. He might pay some cost with his elevating that doesn’t come in the form of Ks, but BABIP. But nonetheless he should be very good, even if it is “just” a Konerko/Teixeira type of player and not the next Miggy like some Philly fans probably think right now.

We hoped you liked reading Recent Historical Comps for Rhys Hoskins by Dominikk85!

Please support FanGraphs by becoming a member. We publish thousands of articles a year, host multiple podcasts, and have an ever growing database of baseball stats.

FanGraphs does not have a paywall. With your membership, we can continue to offer the content you've come to rely on and add to our unique baseball coverage.

Support FanGraphs

newest oldest most voted

Watch out for survivor bais! By using 1,500 PAs as a cut off, you’ve excluding any and all players who may fit this profile, but who’s results caused them to drop out of the league in a couple seasons or less. I’m not sure how much the comps would change by casting a wider net, but it is not surprising that they look decent given that all the washouts have been excluded.